Cliven Bundy's Arrest Caps Years Of Calls For Government To Take Action

Feb 11, 2016
Originally published on February 12, 2016 10:29 am

The defiant leader of the anti-federal lands movement, Nevada rancher Cliven Bundy, is now facing multiple felony charges — including conspiracy and assault on a federal officer — in the 2014 standoff at his Nevada ranch.

Bundy, who inspired the occupation of Malheur National Wildlife Refuge, was arrested at the airport in Portland, Ore., Wednesday night, apparently on his way to Malheur.

In a 32-page criminal complaint, prosecutors allege Bundy and his co-conspirators led a massive, armed assault against federal officers in April 2014 near the town of Bunkerville, Nev.

According to the U.S. attorney for Nevada, Bundy and his armed supporters on horseback effectively ambushed federal Bureau of Land Management officials as they were trying to round up 400 of Bundy's cows illegally grazing on federal land.

The tense dispute ignited a fierce debate over federal land management and cattle grazing that continued for the past month in Oregon. But Bundy's self-described "range war" has always been about more than cows.

"What's at stake here? Freedom, liberty and statehood, that's what's at stake here," Bundy told me when I visited his ranch in southeastern Nevada shortly after the 2014 standoff.

That hot summer day, Bundy sat between two bodyguards. Photos of his 14 children and framed Mormon scripture hung on the wall behind him.

"[Federal authorities] was acting like an army coming against 'we the people,' " Bundy said at the time.

"We the people" is a constant Cliven Bundy refrain. He has flouted federal grazing laws and four prior court orders because he believes his Mormon ancestors arrived in the region and claimed a "right" to this land, predating the federal territories — an argument often disputed by historians who study the American West.

Bundy owes the federal Bureau of Land Management, or BLM, more than $1 million in leases and fines.

After the 2014 standoff, Bundy enjoyed a few weeks in the national spotlight, and was a darling of some talk show hosts. Most distanced themselves from the rancher when a video surfaced of him espousing racist views about the African-Americans he said he's came into contact with in nearby Las Vegas.

"I've often wondered, were they better off as slaves, picking cotton, having family life and doing things, or are they better off under government subsidy?" Bundy said in the video, apparently filmed a few days after the 2014 standoff.

But after all the attention started to fade, the federal government still didn't act against Bundy. The BLM completely pulled out of the region, and Bundy and his supporters declared victory — until Wednesday night.

"I've been waiting for this for a long time," says Alan O'Neill, a retired park superintendent at Lake Mead National Recreation Area, which spans the Arizona-Nevada border near Bundy's ranch.

O'Neill's first brushes with Cliven Bundy's defiance began in the late 1990s, when Bundy's cows were illegally grazing on park service land. He said there was a plan in place to remove them, but it was stopped back then at the last minute because the federal government worried about another Waco.

"I thought that the government should have moved quicker on Cliven Bundy, but I'm just happy that they did," O'Neill says.

It's not clear how Bundy's arrest will affect his followers and the larger anti-federal lands movement. Reached by cellphone on Wednesday before she began negotiating with the Oregon occupiers and encouraging them to surrender, Nevada state Rep. Michele Fiore was as defiant as ever.

"Across the Western states, this is a pattern of behavior where the BLM has literally become a bureaucracy of terrorism," she said.

If convicted, prosecutors say, Cliven Bundy faces up to 42 years in prison and fines up to $1.5 million.

Copyright 2016 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

The man who inspire the Oregon occupation, Nevada rancher Cliven Bundy, is also in jail today. He was arrested at the Portland Airport last night apparently on his way to the refuge. Bundy is facing multiple felony charges that include conspiracy and assault on a federal officer for the 2014 standoff at his Nevada ranch. NPR's Kirk Siegler reports.

KIRK SIEGLER, BYLINE: The 32-page criminal complaint alleges that Cliven Bundy and his coconspirators led a massive armed assault against federal officers in April of 2014 near Bunkerville, Nev. According to the U.S. attorney for Nevada, Bundy and his armed supporters on horseback effectively ambushed the feds as they were trying to round up 400 of Bundy's cows illegally grazing on federal land. But Cliven Bundy's self-described range war has always been about more than cows.

CLIVEN BUNDY: Yeah, well, come on in.

SIEGLER: After the standoff, I drove to his ranch house more or less unannounced and was welcomed into his living room.

BUNDY: On the Bundy ranch, we're about 80 miles northeast of Las Vegas.

SIEGLER: Bundy sat between two bodyguards. Photos of his 14 children and framed Mormon scripture hung on the walls behind him.

BUNDY: What's at stake here - freedom and liberty and statehood. That's what's at stake here.

SIEGLER: That is a constant Cliven Bundy refrain. He's defied the federal grazing laws and four prior court orders because he believes his Mormon ancestors were here first and claimed a right to this land predating the federal territories. It's an argument often disputed by Western historians. Bundy owes the Federal Bureau of Land Management more than a million dollars in leases and fines.

BUNDY: They was acting - I don't know - acting like an army coming against we, the people.

SIEGLER: Bundy enjoyed a few weeks in the national spotlight, a darling of some talkshow hosts, but most would distance themselves from the rancher when a video surfaced of him espousing racist views about African-Americans.

(SOUNDBITE OF ARCHIVED RECORDING)

BUNDY: And I've often wondered, you know? Were they better off as slaves picking cotton and having family life and doing things, or are they better off under government subsidy.

SIEGLER: But after all the attention started to fade, the federal government still didn't act against Bundy. The BLM pulled completely out of the region, citing safety concerns, and Bundy said he won, until last night.

O'NEILL: I guess I've been waiting for this for a long time.

SIEGLER: Alan O'Neill is a retired park superintendent at Lake Mead National Recreation Area. His first brushes with Cliven Bundy's defiance began in the late 1990s when Bundy's cows were illegally grazing on park service land.

O'NEILL: I thought that the government should have moved quicker on Cliven Bundy, but I'm just happy that they did.

SIEGLER: It's not clear how Bundy's arrest will affect his followers and the larger anti-federal lands movement. Yesterday, reached by cell phone before she began negotiating with the Oregon occupiers, Nevada State Representative Michelle Fiore seemed as defiant as ever.

MICHELE FIORE: Across the western states, this is a pattern of behavior where the BLM has literally become a bureaucracy of terrorism.

SIEGLER: If convicted, prosecutors say Cliven Bundy faces up to 42 years in prison and fines of up to $1.5 million. Kirk Siegler, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.