Higher-Tech Fake Eggs Offer Better Clues To Wild-Bird Behavior

May 26, 2015
Originally published on May 26, 2015 8:42 pm

Since the 1960s, biologists have made fake eggs for some studies of bird behavior. But Mark Hauber of Hunter College in New York says this kind of scientific handicraft is not exactly his forte.

"I'm a terrible craftsperson," he admits.

That's why Hauber is pioneering the use of 3-D printing technology to quickly produce made-to-order fake eggs, taking a bit of old-school science into the 21st century.

Researchers traditionally have made artificial eggs for experiments out of wood or clay or plaster, and then painstakingly painted them. But Hauber says his plaster of Paris eggs look awful. "They look like pears instead of eggs."

The particular eggs that interest him are the speckled eggs of cowbirds. Like cuckoos, these birds lay their eggs in the nests of other species. Sometimes the eggs get accepted, but sometimes they get tossed out of the nest. Scientists want to understand how birds perceive the eggs and what characteristics make the difference.

"It could be the size, it could be speckling itself or the lack thereof, and it could be the color — beige versus robin blue," Hauber explains.

All of this and more can be tested with fake eggs, he says. "Instead of using natural eggs, it's best to use fake eggs, because you can control the size, and shape and the color much more accurately."

Hauber remembers his first fake egg.

"In 1997, I went into a craft store and bought a beige speckled egg, which looks very much like a cowbird egg," he says, recalling that it was actually an Easter decoration. He put it in the nest of a gray catbird, which promptly tossed it out.

But usually, the right egg for a particular experiment can't be found in a store, and researchers have to make it themselves.

So when affordable 3-D printers became available, Hauber was intrigued. These machines generally create objects in plastic that are based on computer models of the object. Hauber bought a 3-D printer and tested its ability to make a fake egg.

"I loved it," he says. "It had the shape of a cowbird egg, because we designed it as such. It had the weight of a cowbird egg." Plus, he adds, the process was standardized, so they could print as many identical eggs as they wanted. His lab has now made hundreds of fake eggs in the printer.

Hauber and his colleagues published a study in the current issue of the journal PeerJ showing that robins, at least, treat the printed eggs like real cowbird eggs — at least when the shells aren't painted robin's egg blue.

Christie Riehl, a biologist at Princeton University, was impressed by this study because it used a whole range of fake cowbird eggs — from small round ones to long skinny ones.

"You can imagine, it would be really labor-intensive and time-intensive to individually handcraft eggs that exploit that whole range of variation," Riehl says, "and it would be very difficult to find commercially available eggs — like even wooden eggs or something — that would have the properties of size and shape that you're trying to test."

She speaks from experience; Riehl has personally made dozens of eggs the old-fashioned way. She's excited by the potential of this technology, not just for fake eggs, but for all sorts of knickknacks needed in experiments.

"With 3-D printing, it's the possibility of being able to make exactly what you want," Riehl says. "And not only that, but you can share those designs with other researchers so they can replicate your results with exactly the same methods."

The printed eggs aren't perfect yet. The colors aren't great — scientists still have to paint them.

And while Hauber has been able to print hollow eggs, the plastic shells are currently too strong to be pierced by a bird's beak. That's important, because piercing an egg is how some species get rid of it.

Hauber is now dreaming of somehow creating an egg that can be punctured. He's noticed some sugar-shelled treats that chefs make, shaped like eggs and filled with ice cream.

Those fake eggs have "a very fragile shell," he says, "so I might try that technique."

But he's also still trying to do it with his 3-D printer.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:

In science, there are huge experiments that use massive, multibillion-dollar machines. And there are more modest studies, jerry-rigging stuff from around the house or crafting objects by hand. One example of that - people who study bird behavior have a long tradition of making fake bird eggs. And NPR's Nell Greenfieldboyce reports, this particular scientific handicraft is now going high-tech.

NELL GREENFIELDBOYCE, BYLINE: There are some tricky birds, like cowbirds and cuckoos, that lay their eggs in the nests of other species. Sometimes the eggs get accepted, sometimes they get tossed out of the nest. Biologist Mark Hauber studies cowbirds at Hunter College in New York. He wants to know, what is it about a speckled cowbird egg that makes it either acceptable or not?

MARK HAUBER: It could be the size, it could be the speckling itself or the lack thereof, and it could be the color - beige versus robin blue.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: Since the 1960s, scientists have used fake eggs to test birds' reactions to all these different things, partly because real eggs from wild birds are hard to come by.

HAUBER: It's tough using natural eggs. It's best to use fake eggs because you can control the size, the shape and the color much more accurately.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: He remembers his first fake egg.

HAUBER: In 1997, I went into a craft store and bought a beige speckled egg, which looks very much like a cowbird egg.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: It was actually an Easter decoration. But most of the time, Hauber and other scientists can't just go into a store and buy the perfect artificial egg. They have to make eggs for experiments by hand, using wood or Plaster of Paris or clay and then painstakingly paint them.

Hauber says all of this is not his forte.

HAUBER: I'm a terrible craftsperson.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: He says his plaster eggs are awful.

HAUBER: They look like pears instead of eggs.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: So when affordable 3-D printers became available, Hauber thought, great. These machines take 3-D computer models of an object and then create that object out of plastic. Hauber bought one and tested its ability to print a fake egg.

HAUBER: I loved it. It had the shape of a cowbird egg because we designed it as such. It had the weight of a cowbird egg, and it was standardized across our hundreds and hundreds of eggs that we have printed.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: They've now published a study in the journal PeerJ showing that robins, at least, treat the printed eggs like real cowbird eggs - they throw them out of the nest.

Christie Riehl is a bird biologist at Princeton University. She was impressed by this study because it used a whole range of fake cowbird eggs, from small round ones, to long skinny ones.

CHRISTIE RIEHL: You can imagine it would be really labor-intensive and time intensive to individually handcraft eggs that exploit that whole range of variation. And it would be very difficult to find commercially available eggs, like, even wooden eggs or something that would have the properties of size and shape that you're trying to test.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: She speaks from experience. She's made dozens of eggs the old-fashioned way. She's excited by the potential of this technology, not just for fake eggs, but all sorts of knickknacks for experiments.

RIEHL: With 3-D printing, it's the possibility of being able to make exactly what you want. And not only that, but you can share those designs with other researchers so they can replicate your results with exactly the same method.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: The printed eggs aren't perfect yet. The colors aren't great. Scientists still have to paint them. And while Hauber has been able to print hollow eggs, the plastic shells are currently too strong to be pierced by a bird's beak. That's important because piercing an egg is how some species get rid of it. Hauber is now dreaming of somehow making a pierce-able egg - maybe out of sugar.

HAUBER: I did see a way of how cooks make fake eggs and fill it with ice cream that comes with a very fragile shell, so I might try that technique.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: But he's also still trying to do it with his 3-D printer. Nell Greenfieldboyce, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.