Most Active Stories
- Former UNH Student Goes It Alone In Criminal Court, Wins 'Not Guilty' Verdict
- Update: Speaker Demands Apology For Abortion Remark During Debate Over Fourth Graders' Bird Bill
- Update: N.H. AG Says Murder-Suicide Likely In Deaths Of Bedford Mother, Two Children
- Report: Former Chief Justice Banned From UNH Law's Rudman Center
- Why Human Feeding Can Hurt Deer
Thu July 24, 2014
Do Heat-Sensitive Inmates Have A Right To Air Conditioning?
Originally published on Fri July 25, 2014 7:40 pm
The exact cause of prisoner Jerome Murdough's death at Rikers Island in February is still under investigation. But the temperature in the cell when he was found in New York City's biggest jail was at least 100 degrees.
The death of Murdough, who had severe mental illness, called renewed attention to a long-standing problem: maintaining reasonable temperatures in jails and prisons.
The high temperatures at some U.S. facilities can form a dangerous — even deadly — combination with the aging inmate population. Medications can make the mentally ill more susceptible to heat, and some prison guards say it's not safe for them, either.
Dr. Susi Vassallo grew up in Texas, so she's not afraid of heat. But the physician and New York University medical school professor still remembers her reaction when she stood in a non-air-conditioned prison cell one summer.
"When you closed the ... doors, they had just little dots in them, which provided any ventilation from the outside," she says. "Even after five minutes ... it was absolutely stifling — it was inconceivable to live there 23 hours a day, day after day."
Vassallo, an expert on heat-related illnesses, is often called to testify in lawsuits about temperatures in jails and prisons. She says that for most people, those conditions are uncomfortable, but that those with some health conditions — including high blood pressure and diabetes, or those taking certain medications — can be much more sensitive.
For those prisoners, exposure to heat can lead to long-term health consequences or death. And the number of inmates prone to this sensitivity has been growing; the elderly prison population has been increasing for years, and people with mental illness make up a disproportionate percentage of inmates in the U.S.
Prisoners' rights lawyers and others have been arguing for decades about what constitutes a reasonable temperature. One lawyer, Mercedes Montagnes, filed a lawsuit last year demanding that the heat index — a calculation of heat and humidity — on Louisiana's death row not go above 88 degrees. A judge agreed and ordered air conditioning installed, but that's on hold as the state appeals the decision.
Montagnes knows that plenty of people outside prison don't have air conditioning. But prisoners have a right to reasonable temperatures and can't escape the heat the way the unincarcerated can, she says.
"Those individuals have the ability to go to a freezer, to get cold water, to go to a mall, to go to a movie theater ... to take action in order to mitigate the effect of the heat on them," she says.
The argument for air conditioning prisons has found allies in some unlikely places. Last year, a group of prison guards from Texas joined a lawsuit against the state's Department of Corrections.
Lance Lowry, a former prison guard in Texas who now works with the guards union, says the corrections officers have many of the same heat-sensitive health conditions as prisoners — obesity, diabetes, high blood pressure, even mental illness.
"Officers frequently suffer from heat cramps and a lot of heat illnesses," Lowry says.
He says prisoners are harder to manage in the heat, too — there are more fights and more psychiatric emergencies.
Texas is among several states facing lawsuits over temperatures in its correctional facilities — of the more than 150,000 prison beds in the state, only about 550 are climate-controlled. Because of that litigation, state officials wouldn't talk on the record, but the state corrections department said in a statement that it is trying to mitigate the high temperatures. Those efforts include purchasing more than $50,000 in industrial-grade cooling fans to test at seven facilities.
Former Texas warden Keith Price, now a professor of criminology and sociology at West Texas A&M University, said that it's important to accommodate heat-sensitive prisoners, but that inmates also need to acknowledge that prison is not a five-star hotel.
"You know, they don't get to go get a cheeseburger whenever they want to, either," Price said. "So, I mean, you know there's a certain amount of things that you give up when you become incarcerated."
ROBERT SIEGEL, HOST:
Earlier this year, a prisoner with severe mental illness died in an overheated cell at Rikers Island, the largest jail in New York City. When he was found, the temperature in his cell was at least 100 degrees - the exact cause of his death is still under investigation. But Alisa Roth reports the case is renewing attention to a long-standing problem in jails and prisons.
ALISA ROTH, BYLINE: Dr. Susi Vassallo grew up in Texas. So she’s not afraid of heat. But she still remembers her reaction when she stood in an un-air-conditioned prison cell one summer.
SUSI VASSALLO: When you closed the doors. they had just little dots in them, which provided any ventilation from the outside. Even after five minutes, it was absolutely stifling, it was inconceivable to live there 23 hours a day, day after day.
ROTH: Vassallo is a physician and professor at NYU’s medical school. And an expert on heat-related illnesses. Who’s often called to testify in lawsuits about temperatures in jails and prisons. She says for most people those conditions are uncomfortable. But for some people, they’re actually dangerous because health conditions or medications they take make them more sensitive.
VASSALLO: Specific conditions, such as mental illness or high blood pressure or diabetes, we think of those conditions and the medications used to treat as rendering those people more, more susceptible to heat.
ROTH: Prisoners’ rights lawyers - and others - have been arguing, literally for decades about what constitutes a reasonable temperature. But the issue has taken on more urgency, because the populations of both elderly and mentally ill prisoners have been growing.
One of those lawyers is Mercedes Montagnes. She says prisoners have a right to certain things.
MERCEDES MONTAGNES: Food, access to drinking water, a roof over their heads, medical care.
ROTH: And, she argues, reasonable temperatures. She filed a lawsuit last year demanding that the heat index equal a calculation of heat and humidity - on Louisiana’s death row not go above 88 degrees.
She knows plenty of people outside prison don’t have air conditioning. But, unlike prisoners, they have the freedom to do something about it:
MONTAGNES: Of course those individuals have the ability to go to a freezer, to get cold water, to go to a mall, to go to a movie theater
ROTH: And the argument for air conditioning prisons has found allies in some unlikely places. Last year, a group of prison guards from Texas joined a lawsuit against the state’s Department of Corrections.
LANCE LOWRY: The officers are required to enter housing areas and work in housing areas where the inmates are housed and are exposed to this constant bombardment of heat.
ROTH: Lance Lowry is a former prison guard in Texas. Who now works with the guards’ union. He says guards have many of the same health conditions as prisoners - obesity, diabetes, high blood pressure. Even mental illness.
LOWRY: Officers frequently suffer from heat cramps and a lot of heat illnesses.
ROTH: He says prisoners are harder to manage in the heat. There are more fights and more psychiatric emergencies. Texas is among several states facing lawsuits over temperatures in its correctional facilities. And because of the ongoing litigation it wouldn't talk on the record. But in a statement, the corrections department said it tries to mitigate the high temperatures. Keith Price is a professor of criminology and sociology at West Texas A and M. And a former Texas warden. He says prison is not a five-star hotel, and prisoners need to acknowledge that.
KEITH PRICE: You know, they don’t get to go get a cheeseburger whenever they want to, either. So I mean you know there’s a certain amount of things that you give up when you become incarcerated.
ROTH: On the other hand, he says, it’s important to accommodate prisoners who are heat-sensitive. The challenge is it is hard to know exactly how many prisoners are living in what we considered overheated conditions. But for example lawyers say that if the more than 150,000 prisons beds in Texas, only around 550 are climate controlled. For NPR News, I'm Alisa Roth in New York. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.