How Bird Beaks Got Their Start As Dinosaur Snouts

May 12, 2015
Originally published on May 13, 2015 12:01 pm

Scientists say they have reversed a bit of bird evolution in the lab and re-created a dinosaurlike snout in developing chickens.

"In this work, we can clearly see a comeback of the characteristics which we see in some of the first birds," says Arhat Abzhanov, an evolutionary biologist at Harvard University.

The ancestors of birds are a group of dinosaurs that includes the famous velociraptor, Abzhanov says. This group of meat-eaters had long snouts, small brains and eyes, and lots of teeth. Somehow they transformed into birds, which have none of those things.

Bhart-Anjan Bhullar, another member of the research team at Yale University, says the goal is to understand exactly how birds became birds. "What's the deep history of birdiness?" wonders Bhullar. "How did the different parts of their body plan form?"

In particular, he and his colleagues are interested in birds' distinctive beak, which Bhullar calls "this insane sort of snout that they have."

To hunt for clues about the origin of the beak, the researchers have been studying various kinds of animal embryos, from birds like emus and chickens to nonbird reptiles like alligators, which are birds' closest living relatives.

Their work led them to two specific genes. These genes are active in the middle of the face-forming region of bird embryos, but not in the middle of that region in the embryos of other animals.

The team did an experiment to see what would happen if they blocked the effect of that localized gene activity in chicken embryos.

Bhullar says he remembers the night he put the altered, developing chicks under a microscope, and saw that they had unusual, broad snouts.

"That was a pretty remarkable moment," he recalls. "That's a moment that will stay with me, I think."

Instead of the normal bone structure that would form a beak, he says, these protochickens had a pair of small, rounded bones that looked "like those in a dinosaur, like archaeopteryx or velociraptor, or in any other reptile — like an alligator."

A report on the study appears this week in the journal Evolution. But don't expect the scientists to create lab-grown dinosaurs — that would be a whole lot harder than just trying to restore some of the traits that existed in the first birds.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

We have a new answer to an old question - which came first, the chicken or the egg?

RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:

The answer - a dinosaur. Chickens, like all birds, descended from dinosaurs.

INSKEEP: And one team of scientists recently managed to reverse that evolution just a bit. NPR's Nell Greenfieldboyce explains.

NELL GREENFIELDBOYCE, BYLINE: The ancestors of birds are a group of dinosaurs that includes the velociraptor. These meat-eaters had long snouts, small brains and eyes, lots of teeth. Somehow, they transformed into birds, which have none of those things. This fascinates Bhart-Anjan Bhullar. He's a researcher at Yale University who wants to understand how birds became birds.

BHART-ANJAN BHULLAR: What's the deep history of sort of bird-iness, and how did the different parts of their body plan form?

GREENFIELDBOYCE: He's interested in one bird part in particular.

BHULLAR: The bird beak.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: To hunt for clues about the origin of the beak, he and his colleagues studied various kinds of animal embryos and zeroed in on two genes. They're active in the middle of the face-forming region of bird embryos. Bhullar did an experiment to see what would happen if they blocked the effect of that activity in chicken embryos. Bhullar says he remembers the night he put those developing chicks under a microscope and saw they had unusual, broad snouts.

BHULLAR: That was a pretty remarkable moment. That's a moment that will stay with me, I think.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: Instead of the normal bone structure that would form a beak, these proto-chickens had a pair of small, rounded bones.

BHULLAR: That looked, for all the world, like those in a dinosaur like archaeopteryx or velociraptor or any other reptile, like an alligator.

GREENFIELDBOYCE: A report on the study appears in the journal Evolution, but don't expect them to bring back dinosaurs in the lab. That would be a whole lot harder than just trying to restore some of the traits that existed in the first birds. Nell Greenfieldboyce, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.