Seeking Empathy, 'Shots Fired' Creators Flip The Script On Police Shootings

Mar 22, 2017
Originally published on March 22, 2017 6:41 pm

I'll be honest; at first, I feared the whole series was a bit of a dodge.

Watching the first episode of Shots Fired — Fox's highly anticipated limited series about a federal investigation into a police shooting in a small North Carolina town — one thing became clear rather quickly.

The shooting, which draws two hotshot investigators from the Department of Justice, involves the town's only black police officer, who kills an unarmed, white 19-year-old.

At a time when most broadcast networks struggle to reflect the conversation on race and policing sparked by the deaths of black men like Michael Brown, Eric Garner and Philando Castile — more on that later — I worried Shots Fired would be another show that looked away, even after the show's investigators realized that local police were also covering up the death of an unarmed black teen at the hands of a white cop.

But Shots Fired co-creator Reggie Rock Bythewood told me he had a specific reason for beginning the 10-episode series with the murder of a white teenager by a black police officer.

He wanted non-black viewers to care about the victims of police shootings, too.

"That case ... forces a segment of the audience to look at it from a different view," notes Bythewood, a black man whose grandfather was a police officer who gave him "the talk" about how to handle himself if a racist police officer stopped him for any reason. "[It] forces people, in a way, to say 'What if that was your child? ... What if it looked like your son?' It challenges the audience more."

His wife, Gina Prince-Bythewood, also co-created the show. She says they were inspired, in part, by the support some people showed for George Zimmerman back in 2013, when he was acquitted of charges resulting from killing unarmed black 17-year-old Trayvon Martin.

"It was shocking to us after the Zimmerman verdict — it was so personal and emotional to us and to our son," she says, noting that her son cried. "And then to turn on the TV or go online and see people start to make excuses for everything that happened. And it felt that they weren't seeing Trayvon as their child."

Both Bythewoods are directors, producers and writers. They've got an impressive list of credits together and separately, including the films Love and Basketball, Get on the Bus, and Beyond the Lights and the TV show A Different World.

So when they decided to make a TV drama about a police shooting, they tapped an A-list cast. Richard Dreyfuss plays a wealthy booster of the local police. Helen Hunt is the governor of North Carolina, torn between black residents who fear a coverup of the black teen's death and white residents who wonder why the Caucasian teen's death hasn't become a civil rights issue.

Stuck in the middle are the two DOJ representatives, a straight arrow prosecutor played by Stephan James and a rebellious, street smart investigator, played by Sanaa Lathan.

There are bits here that shine: When a crowd of black people surrounding one shooting scene is pushed around by police, they whip out smartphones to record video and hold up their hands in a silent, #BlackLivesMatter moment.

And Aisha Hinds — who is having a moment playing Harriet Tubman on WGN's Underground and civil rights activist Fannie Lou Hamer on HBO's movie All the Way -- is captivating as a local pastor wavering between capitalizing on the controversy and following her values.

But for all its ambition, Shots Fired has a lot of clunky dialogue where characters are used to dramatize different sides of an argument, instead of reacting as people. The pastor played by Hinds, for example, yells at the federal prosecutor for coming to town only when a white teen is killed, only to have a white man respond with, "So only black lives matter?"

It's a bit like an earnest high school civics class debate turned into TV drama.

But at least Shots Fired is trying to deal directly with the racial and social impact of questionable police shootings. I've been amazed at how many new cop shows this year seem hesitant to focus on the issues that sparked nationwide protests over the past few years.

The Department of Justice released a report earlier this year saying the Chicago Police Department was poorly trained and too quick to use excessive force, especially against black and Latino suspects. But when NBC's Chicago Justice centered an episode on an officer accused of fatally injuring a black suspect during an arrest — spoiler alert — the officer wasn't guilty of the crime.

And at a time when there are serious questions about how to curb the violence in poor Chicago neighborhoods, Fox's new series APB depicts a tech billionaire taking over a police precinct in the city, having adventures which feel more escapist than incisive.

So kudos to Shots Fired for trying to make a statement, even if it falls short at times. Fox only made six of the limited series' 10 episodes available to TV critics before the show launches, so I'm hopeful the remaining episodes will improve.

Because, given how polarized our real-life political dialogue has become, it's great to see an ambitious series tackle a tough social issue by asking viewers to feel a little empathy, first.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

KELLY MCEVERS, HOST:

Also on TV tonight, a new show looking at racially charged police shootings. The 10-episode series on FOX is called "Shots Fired." NPR TV critic Eric Deggans says the show is better at exploring explosive emotions than it is at providing deeper insight.

ERIC DEGGANS, BYLINE: "Shots Fired" begins with a horrific incident...

(SOUNDBITE OF TV SHOW, "SHOTS FIRED")

TRISTAN MACK WILDS: (As Deputy Joshua Beck) Shots fired, shots fired. I need some units. Shots fired. I need some units. Shots fired.

UNIDENTIFIED ACTRESS: (As character, over radio) All units, all units respond to...

DEGGANS: ...The shooting of an unarmed 19-year-old by a police officer in a small North Carolina town. But when federal prosecutor Preston Terry, who happens to be black, is assigned to investigate the case, his supervisor explains a key detail.

(SOUNDBITE OF TV SHOW, "SHOTS FIRED")

MIKE PNIEWSKI: (As Julian Carroll) Governor called me personally. It's a black cop and a white kid. She wants a black prosecutor out front - optics. This climate, only a black man can indict this black cop without inciting tensions if he's guilty.

DEGGANS: The outlook for the officer only gets worse when video surfaces of a racist joke he made at a party for his graduation from the police academy.

(SOUNDBITE OF TV SHOW, "SHOTS FIRED")

UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #1: (As character) Just graduating from the academy. Any last words?

WILDS: (As Deputy Joshua Beck) Finally got my license to shoot these crackers.

(LAUGHTER)

UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #1: (As character) That's right. My boy's bulletproof.

DEGGANS: About halfway through the first episode, federal investigators learn local police are also covering up the shooting death of a black teen by a white officer. That's when "Shots Fired" expands its scope and begins to show how these two deaths produce very different reactions from police, the media and the community.

When I caught up with the show's co-creator, Reggie Rock Bythewood, at a press reception, he explained why "Shots Fired" began with the white teen's death. It's about getting non-black audience members to care about the victims of police shootings, too.

REGGIE ROCK BYTHEWOOD: What that case gives us forces a segment of the audience to look at it from a different point of view, forces people in a way to say what if that was your child?

DEGGANS: His wife, Gina Prince-Bythewood, co-created the show. She says the way some people cheered the 2013 acquittal of George Zimmerman for killing unarmed black 17-year-old Trayvon Martin convinced her there were people out there who needed some lessons in empathy.

GINA PRINCE-BYTHEWOOD: It was shocking to us after the Zimmerman verdict. It was so personal and emotional to us and to our son. And then to turn on the TV or go online and see people starting to make excuses for everything that happened, and it felt that they were not seeing Trayvon as their child.

DEGGANS: The Bythewoods are both directors, producers and writers. Their credits together and separately include the films "Love And Basketball," "Beyond The Lights" and the TV show "A Different World." "Shots Fired" bears all the signs of a prestige project for Fox. There are A-list costars like Richard Dreyfus and Helen Hunt, along with a jazzy score by Spike Lee's longtime composer Terence Blanchard. The show's two lead actors, Stephan James and Sanaa Lathan, make a great team, playing a straight arrow prosecutor, an unconventional investigator.

But for all its ambition, "Shots Fired" has a lot of clunky dialogue. At times, the characters are simply acting out a political argument instead of responding as people, like in this scene where a black pastor who challenges the federal investigators at a press conference is interrupted by a white man in the crowd.

(SOUNDBITE OF TV SHOW, "SHOTS FIRED")

AISHA HINDS: (As Pastor Janae James) What I don't understand is why you're here. All the murdering of unarmed black man by police across this country, and this is the one that the government is investigating?

UNIDENTIFIED ACTOR #2: (As character) Oh, so only black lives matter?

HINDS: (As Pastor Janae James) I'm sorry, when is the last time you were pulled over by the police and didn't know if you were going to make it out alive?

DEGGANS: Instead of revealing new ways to look at these issues, some scenes told us what we already know, as when that same pastor, played by Aisha Hinds, talks about the value of public protest to an earnest North Carolina governor played by Helen Hunt.

(SOUNDBITE OF TV SHOW, "SHOTS FIRED")

HELEN HUNT: (As Governor Patricia Eamons) I know together we can get ahead of this and keep our city from becoming another Ferguson.

HINDS: (As Pastor Janae James) Ferguson was a tragedy, a rallying cry that spawned a movement, a movement still alive today. Have you ever considered that maybe I do want another Ferguson?

DEGGANS: Fox only provided six of the limited series' 10 episodes early to critics. So I'm hopeful later installments will dig a little deeper and surprise viewers a little more. Because at a moment when political divisions in America couldn't be more heated, there's no better time for a series which approaches tough social issues by asking for a little empathy. I'm Eric Deggans.

(SOUNDBITE OF BONOBO SONG, "DAYS TO COME") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.