In Tennessee, Giving Birth To A Drug-Dependent Baby Can Be A Crime

Nov 18, 2015
Originally published on February 10, 2017 10:03 am

In the United States, a baby is born dependent on opiates every 30 minutes. In Tennessee, the rate is three times the national average.

The drug withdrawal in newborns is called neonatal abstinence syndrome, or NAS, which can occur when women take opiates during their pregnancies.

In the spring of 2014, Tennessee passed a controversial law that would allow the mothers of NAS babies to be charged with a crime the state calls "fetal assault." Alabama and Wisconsin have prosecuted new mothers under similar laws, and now other states are also considering legislation.

Supporters of the laws say they can provide wake-up calls to women dependent on drugs and encourage them to get help. The Tennessee law says that getting treatment for drug use is a valid defense against fetal assault charges. But critics say criminalizing the effects of a woman's drug dependence on her newborn child makes it less likely for her to seek help when it could do the most good.

The problem of NAS is growing nationwide. Nearly 6 in 1,000 babies born in the U.S. in 2012 were diagnosed with NAS, according to a study published in the Journal of Perinatology in August. That's nearly double the level seen in 2009.

In Tennessee, billboards on the side of highways declare, "Your baby's life shouldn't begin with detox," with an image of a newborn baby's foot attached to a medical monitor. The signs are strategically placed in areas with the biggest substance abuse problems, like Oak Ridge — a town surrounded by poor, rural communities in northeastern Tennessee.

On a drizzly Monday afternoon in Oak Ridge, a group of women sits in a circle in a low brick building. Some of these women have their babies — bouncing on their knees or rocking gently in car carriers. These women are all in recovery, and some are recently out of prison for fetal assault. The group is called Mothers and Infants Sober Together, or MIST, and provides outpatient treatment for mothers addicted to drugs.

Each woman takes her turn checking in with Michelle Jones, who runs the MIST program. The women talk about their challenges and triumphs, their cravings. One pregnant woman admits to feeling guilty for being on a medicine prescribed by her doctor to ease her cravings for opiates.

"Can I say something? Don't feel guilty," another woman pipes up, "because it's going to help you right now."

Jones sits in the circle with them, week after week, asking questions and prompting them to open up. It's not an easy task. Many of them were afraid to talk at first.

Avoiding Prenatal Care Out Of Fear

Brittany Crowe used to be one of those women. Now, she shares her story.

"I could have gone [to] a baby doctor at first, but I was scared because of the new law," Crowe tells the group. When she was pregnant with her youngest son, she was addicted to prescription drugs and knew that if she went to a doctor, a drug test would come back positive. So she stayed away. She had no prenatal care through her entire pregnancy. She was so afraid of going to jail and losing custody of her children that she considered giving birth at home.

"I worry about that a lot now," she told us later. "I wonder how many babies are not known about because the mothers are afraid to get help, and then they're born at home and nobody ever knows about these babies. If they're going through withdrawal so bad, they're going to pass away."

Crowe finally went to the hospital 10 minutes before she gave birth. Her son was born with neonatal abstinence syndrome. The Department of Children's Services took him and her older children away and put them in foster care. Crowe enrolled in the MIST program to get clean.

Crowe's experience points to one reason medical professionals and social workers oppose the fetal assault law: They worry that the law will keep women from getting medical care. Dr. Jessica Young, an OB-GYN at Vanderbilt University who specializes in addiction during pregnancy, says the law has made her patients afraid.

"So now they're making decisions on medical care out of fear rather than out of science or what is best for them and their baby's health," she says. "Fear makes people make rash unsafe decisions without the consultation or guidance of a physician."

State Rep. Terri Lynn Weaver, a Republican who co-sponsored the bill, argues that critics misunderstand its intent.

"We want to get these women help," she says. They "weren't getting help — not going to prenatal care anyway. Their mindset is not on prenatal care. The mindset is on the next drug." She hopes the law can act as a wake-up call to addicted women that will motivate them to seek help.

Some of the mothers at MIST told us the law did scare them into getting help. When Jessica Roberts got pregnant, the law drove her to enroll in rehab twice, but it didn't make her quit. She relapsed both times, injecting herself with opiates.

"What finally broke me was, I was 31 weeks. I had tied off to hit myself. And I put my arm on my stomach. And [the baby] kicked my arm off. And that broke me," she says. "To me, it was like my baby saying 'Mom, you can't do this anymore. I need you.' And it hurt."

Treatment Slots Hard To Find

When Roberts wanted help quitting cold turkey, she had a hard time finding it. Not many rehab clinics will detox a pregnant woman, and the few that do have long waiting lists. Doctors disagree on whether detoxing a pregnant woman is really best for mothers and their babies. Instead, most physicians recommend a gradual tapering of less harmful medications like methadone, paired with a comprehensive addiction treatment program. Those programs are scarce, however, and often have long waiting lists of their own.

Young's clinic at Vanderbilt, for instance, has a waiting list of up to eight weeks, and the majority of her patients have to drive over an hour to see her.

At the state Department of Children's Services, Connie Gardner says it feels like Tennessee is "drowning in the drug problem," and nobody has thrown the state a life preserver. She understands why mothers view her office with distrust and fear. The department makes the decision about when babies should be taken from a mother and put into foster care.

"None of these mothers wakes up and says, 'I'm going to abuse my child today,' " Gardner says. "None of them wakes up and says, 'I'm going to be a bad mother.' What I have to remember is that they do. They can get better. What's frustrating, what's disappointing is that we don't have the tools to help them get better."

Even the law's advocates acknowledge that there isn't enough help for the women who want it. Barry Staubus, the district attorney for Sullivan County in the northeast corner of Tennessee, has prosecuted more than 20 drug-using mothers this year.

"Of course I'm for funding programs and making those programs available," he says. "There's always the call for more funding, but we can't let that get in the way of a good idea ... or an effective program."

Staubus believes that there need to be real consequences to women who chronically abuse powerful prescription drugs while pregnant. He says the threat of jail time would scare even the most defiant women, who had been previously unwilling to get into a program.

The Tennessee law is set to expire next year, unless state legislators renew it. So its effectiveness is under close scrutiny.

Births Of Addicted Babies Up In Nashville

At Vanderbilt Hospital's Neonatal Intensive Care Unit in Nashville, the persistent squealing cry of newborns going through drug withdrawal provides an audible reminder that this problem is far from solved. In the year and a half since this law took effect, the numbers of NAS babies have not gone down, says Dr. Stephen Patrick, who researches neonatal abstinence syndrome at the hospital. He saw 100 cases last year, and the hospital is on track to see at least that many this year. He doesn't think punishment is the right way to solve this problem.

NAS is a treatable condition in newborns, he says, and there isn't enough research to know what its long-term effects on a child might be. "There was a lot of concern about the cocaine epidemic and Time magazine calling it a 'lost generation.' I think we should be really cautious in how we frame this moving forward," he says. "The evidence really doesn't support that for neonatal abstinence syndrome. And, in fact, we know that other substances, legal substances such as alcohol, are far more harmful long-term to infants."

On a warm fall afternoon, Crowe and her children are at the park. Her older kids play in a stream as she holds her youngest on her hip. He's 9 months old, with big blue eyes and a tuft of blond hair.

One of her boys runs up to her, a mischievous smile on his face.

"Don't you splash me," she warns, but there's amusement in her voice.

He giggles and Mom gets a faceful of muddy water. She laughs as she wipes it from her eyes. He splashes her again.

Is she having second thoughts about having her children back?

"I think it's a little too late," she says, laughing. "I can honestly say a year ago I wouldn't have been here." She's grateful to be here now. Free of drugs, and finally reunited with her children.

This is the first story in a series that was produced by All Things Considered in collaboration with Nashville Public Radio reporter Blake Farmer.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

ARI SHAPIRO, HOST:

In the United States, a baby is born dependent on drugs every 30 minutes. Tennessee has a rate three times higher than the national average. So the state decided to charge those mothers with a crime. Lawmakers call it fetal assault. Other states are considering similar laws, and I wanted to find out what the impact has been in Tennessee. So I teamed up with somebody who knows this story well - Blake Farmer, reporter with member station WPLN in Nashville. Hey, Blake.

BLAKE FARMER, BYLINE: Hello, Ari.

SHAPIRO: You reported on this law when it was being debated a year and a half ago. And just the other day, we met up in East Tennessee.

FARMER: Yeah, and as I was driving east from Nashville to meet you, I saw this billboard by the interstate. It said, your baby's life shouldn't begin with detox. These messages with pictures of infants are strategically plastered in places with some of the biggest problems - places like Oak Ridge. This is a town surrounded by poor, rural areas. This is Appalachia. Addicts here use prescription painkillers, heroin and other drugs.

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #1: Oh, you're going to drool on me. You're going to drool on me. Oh, you got to throw up? Don't do that.

SHAPIRO: We're at a group called MIST, Mothers and Infants Sober Together. A bunch of women sit in a circle, some of them with their babies, some recently out of prison. They give each other advice and support.

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #2: I'm actually doing pretty well with the medication. I haven't used since then.

UNIDENTIFIED WOMAN #3: Yeah, can I say something? Don't feel guilty about taking Suboxone right now because it's going to help you...

SHAPIRO: There's been a fair amount of reporting on this fetal assault law, but the stories almost never include these voices, the mothers. They opened up to us. They told us they want people to know what's happening.

FARMER: One of the women I talked to was named Brittany Crowe. She told me when she found out she was pregnant, she kind of panicked. She knew that if she went to the doctor and she took a drug test, it would come back positive.

BRITTANY CROWE: The new law that had came out scared me, so I was afraid to get help.

FARMER: She had no prenatal care.

CROWE: None whatsoever.

FARMER: Finally, she went into labor, rushed to the hospital and gave birth in 10 minutes. The state took her newborn and her older kids and put them into foster care. Now she thinks back on the decisions she made.

CROWE: I didn't want to go to the hospital. I worry about that a lot now. I wonder how many babies, you know, they're not known about because the mothers are afraid to get help. And then they're born at home, and nobody ever knows about these babies. I mean, if they're going through withdrawal so bad, they're going to pass away. And, you know, people's not even going to know about them because the mother was afraid to get help.

SHAPIRO: One of the things that most surprised me at this group was the number of women who believe the law is a good motivator. Jessica Roberts got pregnant and she was afraid of the law, so she went to rehab twice. Both times, she relapsed, injecting herself with opiates. Finally, she was in her third trimester getting ready to give birth to a little girl.

JESSICA ROBERTS: What finally broke me was I was 31 weeks. I had tied off to hit myself, and I put my arm on my stomach, and she kicked my arm off. And that broke me. To me, it was like my baby saying, Mom, you know, you can't do this anymore. I need you. And it hurt.

SHAPIRO: It is really hard to know whether this law is driving mothers to get help or scaring them away from it. People who work on this problem in Tennessee tell us they feel like they are drowning in addiction and nobody has thrown the state a life preserver. Michelle Jones is a social worker who runs this organization. She sits in the circle with these women encouraging them to open up.

MICHELLE JONES: I don't necessarily believe that fear is the way to work with this because these women were so afraid. We're looking at fear and judgment, but then when you put a law in place that says, well, we could criminalize you, that doesn't help, that just increases fear and judgment that these women are already facing.

FARMER: Unless the state legislature renews this law, it expires next year. And that's one reason people are paying so much attention to how it's working so far. Some prosecutors here in Tennessee, they refuse to enforce the fetal assault law. One man who's used it a lot is Barry Staubus. He's the district attorney for Sullivan County in the remote northeast corner of the state. He's prosecuted more than 20 drug-using mothers just this year.

BARRY STAUBUS: And as much as I care about the mothers and want to help them, I also care about the babies who never had a choice, who never had a say-so in if they're born on drugs, that never have a say-so on all the impairment and all the disability they may experience because the decision by their mother that they could not give voice and oppose.

SHAPIRO: Since the law took effect last year, the number of babies born having drug-withdrawal symptoms has not gone down. I visited the neonatal intensive care unit at Vanderbilt Hospital in Nashville. This is what it sounds like when a 1-week-old baby goes through drug withdrawal.

(SOUNDBITE OF BABY CRYING)

SHAPIRO: Dr. Stephen Patrick specializes in neonatal abstinence syndrome. He saw a hundred cases here last year. This year, they're on track for at least that many. Still, he doesn't think punishment is the right focus. He says the country overreacted to crack babies in the 1980s, and the same might be true here. It's not clear that babies going through drug withdrawals as newborns will suffer 10 or 20 years down the road.

STEPHEN PATRICK: The evidence really doesn't support that for neonatal abstinence syndrome. And in fact, we know that other substances, legal substance such as alcohol, are far more harmful long-term to infants.

SHAPIRO: This is not just a Tennessee story. Alabama has a similar law and several other states are considering one. Amnesty International's preparing a report about this law. They fear the criminal justice system is getting involved in what's really a healthcare problem.

FARMER: Each new mother we meet in Tennessee is fighting her way back to normalcy day by day.

CROWE: Matthew, James and Jacqueline, come here.

FARMER: Brittany Crowe is the woman we met earlier who received no prenatal care and then lost custody of her children. Now, her youngest is 9 months, perched on her hip. He has big, blue eyes and a tuft of blonde hair. Her older kids are playing in a stream.

SHAPIRO: She's been through a lot to reach this point.

Let me just ask what it is like for you to be here with your kids, seeing them play with each other in the park?

CROWE: It's wonderful. I can honestly say a year ago, I wouldn't have been.

SHAPIRO: One of the boys runs up with a bottle full of muddy water from the stream.

(LAUGHTER)

SHAPIRO: Oh, you got mama all wet. Oh, no. Well, I guess this is what you signed up for, huh?

CROWE: Yeah, I guess so (laughter).

SHAPIRO: Brittany Crowe just graduated from the support program. She has a new job and her kids. This is a woman who found the help she needed. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.