In Diabetes Fight, Lifestyle Changes Prove Hard To Come By In Mexico

Apr 7, 2017
Originally published on April 12, 2017 8:59 am

Let's say you'd like to go for a run in Mexico City.

Dr. Tonatiuh Barrientos, an epidemiologist with Mexico's National Institute of Public Health, thinks that's a good idea — in theory. An expert on diabetes, he'd like to see more people in the Mexican capital get out and exercise to combat the disease.

But as a runner himself, he knows that Mexico City isn't an easy place to jog. In a metropolis of 22 million, there are only a handful of parks where people can run.

"Look, this is a fairly crowded street. It's a pretty noisy street. It's polluted," Barrientos says walking through the Tlalpan neighborhood that lies between his office and his home. "Now just imagine trying to convince yourself to get out there and run."

It's a tough sell. "I mean the only place for you to really run is on the sidewalk. You can't run on the street because you'll probably get run over," he says.

The sidewalk is an uneven mix of broken cement slabs and cobblestones. Street vendors have set up little tables and carts to sell everything from electrical supplies to fried pork cracklings.

There are so many people that it's hard to even walk at a fast clip.

And if you do manage to find a stretch of sidewalk, the elevation in Mexico City combined with the smog and the chances of getting mugged make running a hard thing to get excited about.

"There are a lot of obstacles," Barrientos says as he dodges his way past low-hanging awnings. "And you need to deal with that if you wanted to try to run here."

Professionally, Barrientos has tracked the slow, steady rise in Type 2 diabetes in Mexico. Roughly 14 million Mexicans are now living with diabetes — nearly triple the number who had the disease in 1990.

Barrientos says for too long health officials considered it the responsibility of patients to change their diet and exercise routines. They either did it or didn't. He says now it's become clear that addressing one of Mexico's biggest health crises requires changes at a much higher level and includes lobbying for healthier public spaces where people can easily get out and exercise.

"How do we change the world so that making healthy decisions is a lot easier than it is right now?" he asks.

Diabetes has mushroomed as Mexicans' lifestyles have changed dramatically over the last 40 years. Several generations ago diabetes was almost unheard of in Mexico. Now it's the leading cause of death, according to the World Health Organization. Mexicans with indigenous ancestry have a genetic predisposition for the condition that makes them even more likely to develop it than Caucasians. But a key driver of Type 2 diabetes in Mexico — and globally — is still a person's diet.

Barrientos says current projections show that by 2030, 17 percent of all Mexican adults will have diabetes.

"And that of course opens a lot of questions about sustainability," he says. "Can you really sustain a public health system with 17 percent of your population being diabetic? Especially if you are not prepared to control that diabetes."

Some epidemiologists predict that by 2050, half the adults in the country could suffer from diabetes in their lifetime.

Type 2 diabetes can be reversed with weight-loss surgery in some cases. Uncontrolled, the metabolic disorder can have grave health consequences. It can lead to blindness, nerve damage, kidney failure and, in some cases, foot amputations.

Barrientos and others are now saying the focus of diabetes prevention in Mexico needs to shift away from shaming individuals to looking at new government policies to tackle this mounting health crisis.

"With tobacco we faced the same thing for many, many years. We were trying to encourage people to quit: Because if you don't quit you're going to die!" he says. "The only time that we started to see real change was when we said, 'We are going to change the rules of the game.' The more expensive it is the less you're going to be willing to spend your precious money on something that isn't good for you."

In an effort to reduce soda consumption, the government in 2014 imposed a 1 peso per liter tax on sugar sweetened beverages, the equivalent of about 10 U.S. cents on a standard 2 liter bottle.

At the time Mexico was the leading per capita consumer of soda in the world. In regulatory filings in 2015, Coca-Cola said that the annual consumption of its beverages in Mexico was more than 600 8-ounce servings per person per year. That means that, on average, every Mexican was drinking nearly two glasses of Coke beverages every day. And that doesn't even count the amount of Pepsi or other brands of soda being consumed.

Alejandro Calvillo, the head of a consumer group called El Poder del Consumidor, says soda is making Mexicans sick.

Walking just outside his office in Mexico City, he points out little shops selling Coke and junk food on just about every block. In fact, the red Coca-Cola logo has become a symbol that declares snack shop.

"Coke in Mexico has more than 1.5 million places that sell Coke," Calvillo says. "The presence of these products is everywhere." Calvillo was one of the advocates behind the 2014 soda tax, although he would have liked the tax to have been even higher. A higher tax, he argues, would have pushed down consumption even more and given the government more resources to combat the lifestyle that's linked to diabetes. In indigenous communities in Chiapas, he says, parents put Coke in baby bottles for their infants "and the government isn't doing anything. It's crazy."

Like Barrientos, he says that if Mexico is going to successfully combat diabetes, the rules of the game need to change.

His efforts to get the soda tax increased even more, however, have so far been unsuccessful.

But Jorge Terrazas, the head of ANPRAC, the carbonated beverages trade association in Mexico City, says soda is unfairly blamed for Mexico's extremely high rates of obesity and diabetes.

"There's not conclusive scientific evidence demonstrating the relation between the intake of soft drinks with overweight," he tells NPR.

The average Mexican's daily intake of calories far exceeds the World Health Organization recommendation of 2,000, and Terrazas says the majority of those calories are coming from things other than soda.

But anti-soda campaigners says sugar is a big part of the problem. They say calling for solutions that rely on individuals alone to change their lifestyles won't solve Mexico's diabetes crisis.

Barrientos, the epidemiologist and runner, says the solution is going to require major changes to the way Mexicans live, eat and exercise.

Copyright 2017 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

Here's a fact that tells you something about a country. It's the leading cause of death. The leading cause is different in different nations. In the United States, for example, it's long been heart disease. But as heart disease treatment improves, cancer is starting to take over. In Mexico, the leading cause of death is now diabetes. Researchers say up to half the country could suffer from diabetes if current trends continue. NPR's Jason Beaubien reports on what's going wrong.

(SOUNDBITE OF SIRENS)

JASON BEAUBIEN, BYLINE: Tona Barrientos is a doctor and an epidemiologist with Mexico's National Institute of Public Health in Mexico City. He's also a runner. Walking through the neighborhood in between his office and his home, Barrientos points out that Mexico City is an incredibly hard place to go out for a run.

TONA BARRIENTOS: I mean, the only place for you to really run is the sidewalk. You cannot run on the street because you'll probably get run over.

BEAUBIEN: But the sidewalk isn't the easiest place to jog, either. The surface is an uneven mix of broken cement slabs and cobblestones. Street vendors have set up little tables and carts to sell everything from electrical supplies to fried pork cracklings.

BARRIENTOS: There's a lot of obstacles (laughter), a lot of stuff and people. And there's these street carts and people selling stuff on the street. And you need to deal with that.

BEAUBIEN: Also the smog on some mornings is so thick it makes your lungs tingle.

BEAUBIEN: You can smell it, right? The smell is - it's hard.

BEAUBIEN: To combat obesity, Mexican health officials have been telling people to get out and exercise. But in Mexico City, that could be a hard sell. Type 2 diabetes is a so-called lifestyle disease. And it's mushroomed as Mexicans diets and work habits have changed dramatically over the last 40 years. Several generations ago, diabetes was almost unheard of in Mexico.

Now, it's the leading cause of death. Mexicans with indigenous ancestry also have a genetic predisposition for the condition that makes them more likely to develop the disease than Caucasians. But the main driver of diabetes in Mexico and globally is still what a person eats. Barrientos says that by 2030, 17 percent of all Mexican adults could have diabetes.

BARRIENTOS: And that, of course, opens a lot of questions in terms of sustainability, for instance. So can you really sustain a public health system with 17 percent of your population being diabetic, especially if you are not prepared to control the diabetes?

BEAUBIEN: If left uncontrolled, diabetes can have grave health consequences. It can lead to blindness, nerve damage, even kidney failure. Barrientos says Mexico's experience with anti-tobacco campaigns could hold lessons now for health officials trying to curb diabetes.

BARRIENTOS: The only moment in which we started to see a real change is when we started to change the rules of the game. And we started by saying, well, we're going to increase the price of cigarettes because we know that the more expensive it is, the less you're going to be willing to spend your precious money on something that is not good for you.

BEAUBIEN: In an effort to cut soda consumption, the government in 2014 imposed a one-peso-per-liter tax on sugar-sweetened beverages. At the time, Mexico was the leading per capita consumer of soda in the world. In regulatory filings that year, Coca-Cola said the annual per capita consumption of its beverages in Mexico was more than 600 eight-ounce servings per year.

That means on average, every Mexican was having nearly two glasses of coke products every day. And that doesn't even count the amount of other sugary beverages they were drinking. Alejandro Calvillo, the head of a consumer group called El Poder del Consumidor, says soda is making Mexicans sick. And those cheap sugary drinks are available all over the country.

ALEJANDRO CALVILLO: And you can see the promotions - three liters of Coke, $1.10, something like that.

BEAUBIEN: Walking just outside his office in Mexico City, he points out that there are little shops selling soda and junk food on just about every block.

CALVILLO: Coke in Mexico have more than 1.5 million places that sell Coke. The presence of these products are everywhere.

BEAUBIEN: Calvillo was one of the advocates for the 2014 soda tax, although he would have liked the tax to have been even higher, saying it would have given the government more resources to combat diabetes.

CALVILLO: People no have information. You go to Chiapas in the indigenous community, you can see the kids with baby bottle drinking Coke, you know? And the government is not doing anything. It's crazy, you know?

BEAUBIEN: The head of the country's carbonated beverage trade association, Jorge Terrazas, says soda is being unfairly blamed for Mexico's high rates of obesity and diabetes.

JORGE TERRAZAS: There's not a conclusive scientific evidence demonstrating the relation between the intake of soft drinks with overweight.

BEAUBIEN: He points out that the average per capita intake of calories in Mexico far exceeds the World Health Organization's recommendation of 2,000 per day. And he adds that most of those calories are coming from things other than soda. But Calvillo and other anti-soda campaigners say sugar is a big part of the problem. And they say relying on individuals alone to change their lifestyles won't solve Mexico's diabetes crisis. Jason Beaubien, NPR News.

(SOUNDBITE OF QUANTIC'S "PAINTING SILHOUETTES") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.