How Domestic Violence In One Home Affects Every Child In A Class

Sep 3, 2016
Originally published on September 24, 2016 6:49 pm

Part of our NPR Ed series on mental health in schools.

Every Monday morning at Harvie Elementary School, in Henrico County, Va., Brett Welch stands outside her office door as kids file in.

"The first thing I'm looking for are the faces," says Welch, a school counselor. She's searching for hints of fear, pain or anger.

"Maybe there was a domestic incident at the house that weekend," says Welch. "That's reality for a lot of our kids."

And a reality for a lot of kids in the U.S. While it's difficult to get an exact number, researchers estimate that between 10 and 20 percent of children are exposed to domestic violence each year.

New data quantifies what many teachers and school counselors already know: While such violence often takes place outside of school, its repercussions resonate in the classroom.

It hurts not only the kids who witness the violence, but also their classmates. The harm is evident in lower test scores as well as lower rates of college attendance and completion. And the impact extends past graduation — it can be seen in lower earnings later in life.

"It's a sad story," says Scott Carrell, economist at the University of California, Davis, who has studied this for over a decade.

But, he says, there's one thing he and his colleagues — economists Mark Hoekstra and Elira Kuka — found that can improve the situation "not only for that family but for all the child's classmates." What was it? Reporting domestic violence when it happens.

Violence at home, disruption at school

Brett Welch says she's noticed that kids who act out at school often come from tough home situations.

"Instead of asking for help, they'll start being disruptive," Welch explains.

"They'll ask to go to the bathroom for the 15th time. And when they can't, they'll raise their voices. It can get to the level of throwing a chair — but that's very rare."

Kids who witness domestic violence are more likely to get in trouble at school and have behavioral problems, including being aggressive and bullying their classmates.

Welch says she understands why: School is "where they can feel powerful because they are completely powerless at home."

She often works with those kids one-on-one or in small groups. She wants them to have at least one relationship where "they feel listened to and they feel respected and they know someone cares. That can change everything for them."

Around the country there aren't enough counselors like Welch to go around. Not all states require elementary schools to have counselors. And even where they are required, there can be large caseloads. Sometimes one counselor covers multiple schools and oversees more than 1,000 students.

Welch is stretched so thin she's only at Harvie Elementary two days a week. But a kid may need Welch's support at any time — and mornings in particular are key.

The first 10 minutes after a student arrives at school in the morning is a critical window, Welch says. If she's able to catch them and make them feel heard, "it can completely change their day" — and it can change their classmates' days, too.

Influence on classmates

If one kid is having a hard day, Brett Welch says, it influences the rest of the children in the classroom.

"It takes the teacher's attention, it interrupts learning and it interrupts the flow of the day." She says she can see the impact on classmates' academic work.

Scott Carrell's data confirms what Welch has observed.

He links lots of academic metrics — like test scores, discipline infractions and college graduation rates — with court records on whether a parent has filed a restraining order.

Now, domestic violence and restraining orders happen in all the schools Carrell examined. But they were 10 times more likely to happen in the school serving the poorest population compared with the school serving the wealthiest population. So to make sure he wasn't just seeing the effect of poverty, Carrell came up with a clever solution.

He looked at siblings who come from the same family and go to the same school, but one sibling has a classmate who's struggling with domestic violence and the other sibling doesn't.

Examining lots of sibling pairs and crunching almost two decades worth of data, Carrell found that your classmates, and whether or not they come from a home with domestic violence, influence how well you do in school and beyond.

Measuring harm in dollar figures, Carrell looked at wages when the students grew up. He found that: "exposure to an additional disruptive peer throughout elementary school leads to a 3 to 4 percent reduction in earnings at age 24 to 28."

Carrell says that number adds up quickly — because, in a class of 25 kids, that's a 3 or 4 percent drop in wages for each person. Plus, if your classroom has multiple children from troubled homes, the tests scores get lower and lower and the wages drop gets bigger and bigger with each additional disruptive child.

Carrell argues this has implications for how to make schools and classrooms fair. He says, ideally, we would avoid concentrating disruptive kids in the same classroom or the same school.

And Carrell says his biggest takeaway is that "society has a vested interest in helping those families that are struggling with domestic violence. The more we can help other households, the better off our children will be."

What can be done to improve things?

Carrell and his colleagues found one thing that, they say, really helps: parents reporting the domestic violence.

After reporting it, "things get better."

Carrell says there are three things that might account for this: First, the violence in the homes may have stopped. Second, another adult has decided to make some positive changes in the child's life. Third, people like Brett Welch get involved.

Reporting domestic violence forces the school to pay attention, and often that means the school counselors get involved.

Welch talks to students about finding safe places in their homes. She works on anger management. She helps kids improve their emotional vocabulary.

Vickie Fahed, a kindergarten teacher at Harvie Elementary, says she can see Welch's impact on a child. When Fahed has angry or disruptive children, she sends them down the hallway to see Welch.

"The child comes back so relaxed and so at peace," Fahed says.

When that child is at ease, the whole class can focus. That translates into higher test scores and better graduation rates for the child and their classmates.

All this is great — at least on Mondays and Thursdays, when Welch is here.

"You can tell when she's not here in this building," says Fayed. "It's a big difference. We're like: 'OK, she's not here today? OK, wait till tomorrow.' "

On the days Brett Welch is in the building, she stands by the door as students leave.

"You tell them that you love them because you do," Welch says. "And because maybe that's what they need to be able to get through whatever they need to get through at home."

And, both Brett Welch and Scott Carrell say, if the child's home life gets better, things will get better at school — for that child, and for their classmates.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

MICHEL MARTIN, HOST:

Now we're going to talk about education. In a few minutes, we'll be speaking with the outgoing head of a school district in Washington, D.C. But first, in the U.S., somewhere between 10 and 20 percent of children are exposed to domestic violence each year. Many of these kids are more likely to have behavioral issues and get into trouble in school, yet education systems, especially elementary schools, are often woefully unprepared to help these children. As part of our series on mental health in schools, Gabrielle Emanuel of the NPR Ed team reports.

GABRIELLE EMANUEL, BYLINE: Every Monday at Harvie Elementary School in Richmond, Va., things start the exact same way.

BRETT WELCH: I stand outside my office and the first thing I'm looking for are the faces when they walk in the door.

EMANUEL: Brett Welch is a counselor here. She's scanning the students faces, searching their eyes for hints of fear, pain, anger.

WELCH: Maybe there was a domestic incident at the house that weekend. And that's a reality for a lot of our kids.

EMANUEL: In the hallway is a second-grader. Today, like every Monday, this student seeks out Welch. She's already gotten in trouble with her teacher before school's even started.

UNIDENTIFIED CHILD #1: I get in trouble every day.

WELCH: Well, I know. That's what we're working on, right?

EMANUEL: The 8-year-old is dealing with a hard situation at home. We're not using her name to protect her privacy. She plops down in Welch's office and hides her face. Today's topic - annoying classmates.

WELCH: We don't want them to take your...

UNIDENTIFIED CHILD #1: Do I have to say it?

WELCH: Yeah, it's what we're working on.

UNIDENTIFIED CHILD #1: Power.

WELCH: That's right. You keep your power.

EMANUEL: Welch understands why kids from tough homes act out.

WELCH: Because they're completely powerless at home.

EMANUEL: People like Welch can help. But around the country, there aren't enough counselors like her to go around. Not all states require elementary schools to have counselors. And even in those states where it is required, there are large caseloads. Sometimes one counselor covers multiple schools and oversees more than a thousand students. Welch is stretched so thin she's only at a Harvie Elementary a few days a week. But kids can act out at any time.

WELCH: They'll ask to go to the bathroom for the 15th time. They'll raise their voice. It can get to the level of, you know, throwing a chair or doing something. That's very rare.

EMANUEL: How does that influence the rest of the kids, the classroom?

WELCH: It completely influences the rest of the kids.

EMANUEL: Scott Carrell has the data to prove it. He's an economist at the University of California, Davis.

SCOTT CARRELL: Absolutely. So even within a school, it not only affects your achievement on standardized test scores while you're there, but those persist all the way through high school. You're less likely to go to college, and your income is reduced.

EMANUEL: Carrell looks at lots of data on restraining orders, kid's test scores and their incomes when they grow up. And he found that domestic violence has a big influence, not only on the kids in those families, but also on their classmates. And like lots of problems in education, this issue - domestic violence - affects poor schools more than better-off schools.

So what can be done to improve things? Carrell and his colleagues found one thing that really helps - parents reporting the domestic violence.

CARRELL: Things get better, not only for that family, but for all the child's classmates.

EMANUEL: Carrell says there are three things that might account for this. Number one, that violent person is now out of the kid's life. Number two, another adult has decided to be proactive. Three...

UNIDENTIFIED CHILDREN: Good morning, Ms. Welch.

WELCH: Good morning. How was the weekend?

EMANUEL: School counselors, like Welch. Reporting domestic violence forces schools to pay attention, and school counselors get involved. Welch talks to students about finding safe places in their homes. She works on anger management, and she helps kids improve their emotional vocabulary. Today, Welch is teaching a lesson in Vickie Fahed's kindergarten class.

WELCH: ...Because we're all on the same, what?

UNIDENTIFIED CHILD #2: Page.

UNIDENTIFIED CHILD #3: Team.

UNIDENTIFIED CHILD #4: Level.

WELCH: Page, team, level. You're right. All those answers are right.

EMANUEL: When Welch isn't in the classroom, Vickie Fahed sends angry or disruptive kids down the hallway to see Welch.

VICKIE FAHED: The child comes back so relaxed and so at peace.

EMANUEL: When that kid is at ease, the whole class can focus. That translates into higher test scores and better graduation rates. All this is great, but only on the days when Welch is there.

FAHED: You can tell when she's not here in this building. It's a big difference because we're like, OK, today's not - she's not here today. We have to wait till tomorrow.

EMANUEL: Brett Welch knows she can't help every child, but she says she does what she can.

WELCH: You tell them that you love them because you do and because maybe that's what they need to be able to get through whatever there is to get through at home.

EMANUEL: And if that child's home life gets better, things will get better at school for that child and all their classmates, too. Gabrielle Emanuel, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.