Puzzling Ebola Death Shows How Little We Know About The Virus

Nov 24, 2015
Originally published on November 30, 2015 12:33 pm

"The reality is this outbreak's not over," says Dr. William Fischer, speaking about Ebola. "It's just changed."

Fischer, a professor at the University of North Carolina who's been studying Ebola survivors, was speaking about the new cases in Liberia. On Monday, a 15-year-old died of the disease. The teenager's father and brother have also tested positive for Ebola. Health authorities have not yet determined how the family was infected.

Liberian health officials say the 15-year-old boy visited several clinics in Monrovia last week before finally being directed to an Ebola treatment unit. The more than two dozen health care workers who came into contact with him are among the nearly 160 people now being monitored for signs of Ebola.

The World Health Organization had declared in May and then again in September that transmission of Ebola in Liberia had come to a halt. Both announcements turned out to be premature. In June, a 17-year-old boy died of the disease; the source of his infection was unknown.

And now there are the three new cases.

WHO officials say the latest cases hadn't been in contact with any known Ebola survivors or done anything else that would have put them at obvious risk of getting the disease.

"I think it is a surprise for us all but it also just demonstrates how much we don't know about the virus," says Carissa Guild, a nurse who is in charge of Doctors Without Borders operations in Liberia.

"I think in Liberia now, especially the third time that it's come back, even if we were thinking that maybe it's over and that everything is over, it just shows us once again that Ebola can still come back and we don't really necessarily know where or how," Guild says. " We still have to keep up our vigilance and we still have to be protecting ourselves as health care workers."

This year, researchers have found that the Ebola virus can survive in semen for 9 months or more. This was far longer than what had been the standard message to male Ebola survivors earlier in the epidemic. The original advice for men was to abstain from sex or use condoms for 3 months after they'd recovered. Then in March a Liberian woman got Ebola and died in what's become the first documented case of sexual transmission of the virus. Her sex partner had been discharged from a treatment unit and been declared Ebola free 6 months prior to infecting her.

Last month a Scottish nurse who'd recovered from Ebola in January had the virus begin replicating again in her blood.

Clinics across Monrovia have stepped up infection control measures. Several doctors concede that health care workers let their guard down after Liberia was declared Ebola-free. They weren't wearing protective gowns; some even went back to examining patients with their bare hands.

Rick Sacra is a doctor and an Ebola survivor. In Monrovia, the capital of Liberia, he's worked at ELWA Hospital, which is run by the Christian aid group SIM. Sacra says that as a result of these new cases his clinic has ramped up infection control protocols and even scrambled to get more protective clothing.

But he also has noticed ordinary Liberians are taking the new cases in stride:

"I'm not seeing the public panicking and staying away from the hospital like last year, so I'm encouraged by that."

The news from Liberia makes the work of doctors like William Fischer even more critical.

There are thousands of Ebola survivors in West Africa right now. Many of them are facing various health problems. And they may also be the reservoir that sparks the next major outbreak. Rather than handwringing over what went wrong in the international response to this outbreak, Fischer says, we need to understand how the disease continues to affect the survivors.

"We have to pivot. We can't stop and say, 'Oh what should we have done differently in the beginning of the epidemic,' " Fischer says. "We have to say, 'What do we need to do right now.' "

One of the obvious things is to get a clear understanding of how survivors can or can't pass the virus to others.

Copyright 2015 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

KELLY MCEVERS, HOST:

In Liberia, more than a hundred people are being monitored for Ebola after a teenager died of the disease yesterday. The teenager's father and brother have tested positive. The new cases come after Liberia was declared free of the virus twice. NPR's Jason Beaubien reports there are new questions about what it will take to finally end this epidemic.

JASON BEAUBIEN, BYLINE: Liberian health officials say that a 15-year-old boy sought medical care last week at several clinics in Monrovia before finally being directed to an Ebola treatment unit. More than two dozen health care workers who came into contact with him are now among the nearly 160 people people being monitored for signs of the disease. How the teenager and two of his family members got infected with the virus is still under investigation. The World Health Organization declared in May and then again in September that transmission of Ebola in Liberia had come to a halt. Top WHO officials say the boy and his family hadn't been in contact with any known Ebola survivors or done anything else that would've put them at obvious risk of getting the disease.

CARISSA GUILD: I think it is a surprise for us all, but it also just demonstrates how much we don't know about the virus.

BEAUBIEN: Carissa Guild is in charge of Doctors Without Borders operations in Liberia.

GUILD: I think in Liberia, now especially, the third time that it's come back, I think even if we were thinking that maybe it's over and that everything is over, it just shows us once again that Ebola still could come back. And we don't really necessarily know where or how. We still have to keep up our vigilance, and we still have to be protecting ourselves as health care workers.

BEAUBIEN: Researchers recently have found that the Ebola virus can survive in semen for nine months or more. This was far longer than what had been the standard message to male Ebola survivors earlier in the epidemic. The original advice was to abstain from sex or use condoms for three months after they'd recovered. Then, in March of this year, a Liberian woman got Ebola and died in what's become the first documented case of sexually transmission of the virus. Her sex partner had been discharged from a treatment unit and been declared Ebola-free six months prior to infecting her.

William Fischer from the University of North Carolina has been studying survivors in Liberia and looking specifically at how the Ebola virus persists in some of them in some parts of their bodies.

WILLIAM FISCHER: The reality is the outbreak's not over. It's just changed.

BEAUBIEN: Last month, the Scottish nurse who'd recovered from Ebola in January had the virus come roaring back in her blood. This week, after the reemergence of the cases in Liberia, the Health Ministry is trying to determine exactly how these three family members were infected. In the meantime, medical clinics across Monrovia have stepped up infection control measures. Several doctors concede that health care workers let their guard down after Liberia was declared Ebola-free. They weren't wearing protective gowns, and some even went back to examining patients with their bare hands.

Rick Sacra, a missionary doctor with SIM at the ELWA Hospital on the outskirts of Monrovia, says as a result of these new cases, his clinic has ramped up infection control protocols and even scrambled to get some more protective clothing. But he's also noticed that ordinary Liberians are taking the new cases in stride.

RICK SACRA: I'm not seeing the public panicking and staying away from the hospital or anything like happened last year, so that's good. I'm encouraged by that.

BEAUBIEN: Sacra himself says he isn't worried about getting infected. He came down with Ebola in August of 2014 but survived. He now considers himself to be immune. Jason Beaubien, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.